SB Nation - Login for mobile commenting

Cincy Jungle

Greg Cook: What Could Have Been

Greg Cook

Greg Cook

According to WCPO's Dennis Janson, former Bengals quarterback and University of Cincinnati hall of famer Greg Cook has passed away after being hospitalized for pneumonia. He didn't respond to treatment due to a series of pre-existing conditions.

A source close to the former University of Cincinnati and Bengals quarterback was in the intensive care unit after his health took a turn for the worse Thursday night. His family had gathered Thursday to keep vigil.

Cook broke dozens of passing records at the University of Cincinnati and was scouted and eventually drafted by Cincinnati Bengals founder and head coach Paul Brown with the No. 5 overall pick in the 1969 NFL draft. He became the first rookie quarterback to start the first game of the season, which didn't happen again until 2011, when Andy Dalton started against the Browns in Week 1.

Star-divide

Cook was a rare talent and a natural passer coming out of UC and, with the right coaching, had the potential to be one of the greatest of his time. Cook led the Bengals to three straight wins to start the 1969 Bengals but injured his shoulder in the third game against the Kansas City Chiefs. Backup quarterback Sam Wyche started the next four games, all four losses, before Cook returned in Week 8 to beat the Oakland Raiders. Unfortunately, after playing to a tie in Week 9, the Bengals lost the rest of their games.

In his rookie season, Cook passed for 1,854 yards for 15 touchdowns and 11 interceptions, which earned him the AFL Passing Title and he was named the UPI's Offensive Rookie of the Year. His 9.41 yards per passing attempt is the oldest standing Bengals record and the only one still standing from the time they played at Nippert Stadium. The only Bengals quarterback to get close was Boomer Esiason's 9.21 yards per attempt in 1988, when the Bengals went to the Super Bowl.

Unfortunately, during the third game of the season, Cook had torn his rotator cuff and due to the limited medical technology at the time, the injury went undiagnosed. Instead of receiving the necessary surgery, he only received cortisone shots which helped the pain but allowed his rotator cuff and his shoulder to deteriorate. He had surgery in the offseason where it was discovered that on top of his rotator cuff being torn and his bicep was partially detached.

Cook said in an interview with Sports Illustrated that he felt obligated to finish the season after the team's good start.

"I took cortisone shots and played in pain," he says, "but the shoulder hadn't started to deteriorate yet, so I could still function. I still had the strength. I felt obligated to finish the season. I'd gotten off to a good start. I didn't want to relinquish that."

Doctors were unable to repair Cook's shoulder at the time and he sat out of football for the next two seasons. Cook tried to comeback in 1973, but his injuries stopped him from being able to throw the football like he once did. After that, Cook decided to call it quits.

He said in an interview with The Dayton Daily News:

"I may try to lob a few (passes) between now and then, just to see if there's some kind of medical miracle. But I don't expect one. As far as I'm concerned, this is it. It's all over."

During the NFL Network's countdown of their Top-10 One Hit Wonders, they named Greg Cook No. 1. At one point in the video, tight end Bob Trumpy said, "I don't know what he would have done if he played for 10 or 12 years. I think my fingers would be filled with Super Bowl rings."

Bill Walsh, who was the architect of the Bengals offense, which later became the West Coast Offense, believed that the actual offensive scheme would have been different if he had more time to work with Cook.

"Completely different," he said. "It would have started with the deep strike, and everything would have played off that. It would have set records that never would be broken.

"Greg Cook," he said nostalgically, his eyes getting a little misty. "What a great, great talent. What a terrible shame."

In his short time with the Bengals, Cook made such an impact that the Cincy Jungle community actually picked him as the best player in the history of the team to ever wear No. 12 over quarterbacks Neil O'Donnell and Jack Thompson as well as wide receiver and punt returner Quan Cosby.

After retiring, Cook worked for the United Parcel Service and turned to painting, which was a hobby of his.

Cook has struggled with his health recently and the pneumonia that hospitalized him early this week took his life. Our thoughts are with his family and friends in this difficult time and we will always remember one of the potential greats of the Bengals family.

Of his passing, Bengals owner Mike Brown issued the following statement, in which he names Cook the single most talented player to ever wear a Bengals uniform.

"Greg was the single most talented player we’ve ever had with the Bengals," said Bengals president Mike Brown. "His career was tragically short due to the injury. Had he been able to stay healthy, I believe he would have been the player of his era in the NFL.

"Greg was a personal friend to me," Brown added. "He was a good person whose company I enjoyed over all his years as a player and after that. I feel a great loss at his passing."

Greg Cook was 65 years old.

0 recs  |  14 comments

Comments

Thanks for the memories Mr. Cook
Indeed...

I can only remember back as far as the Ken Anderson days, but if Greg Cook had stayed healthy, there would have been no Anderson for the Bengals, and Cook might have been remembered as the greatest NFL QB of all time. Just listen to Bill Walsh at the beginning of the One Hit Wonders video linked above.

Drew Brees suffered the same injury in 2006, and was back only months later; since the injury he has thrown for almost 30,000 yards and over 200 TDs, staggering numbers (and Super Bowl title as well). This medical technology was not available in 1969. How sad. RIP Greg, you will be missed.

little before my time

but RIP….

Mention Of Greg Cook.

Us old guys stop what we are doing when Greg Cooks nane is mentioned. Greg Cook was always revered as a Great Talent. Greg Cook was an Artist on the field. Greg Cook was an Artist off the field.

chillliiiiii

was up buddy…have been waiting for a chili gem all week….Greg Cooks arm vs Daltons arm….what do you think???

No comparison...

I like Dalton a lot, but Cook had an absolute cannon of an arm. He was superior to Andy (and almost every QB who has ever played) in almost every way. He shredded his shoulder in Week 3 of his rookie season, and still led the league in passing. Not knocking Dalton at all, but people forget how great Cook really was. Great video on his brief career:

http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-network-top-ten/09000d5d807434bc

Take a look at Chili's profile and read his comments

you’ll see why tical said something. He wasn’t being serious. :-)

Sorry about that si

I was just messing with Chili…like Oregon said…just read his posts and you will understand…

Oh, ha!

A Chili gem, I get it. Yeah I was thinking, Dalton has about typical NFL arm-strength, so no way it compares to Cook, even in those days. But maybe you don’t know that much about Cook, it was a long time ago.

I was born around the time when Greg Cook retired, so I didn’t know of him in my lifetime, but I heard stories and saw shows like the NFL one above. So I knew about how good he was and what a sad story it was. I hope he didn’t let such bad luck define the rest of his life, and died a man at peace without regrets. RIP.

So we are cursed for Bo Jackson

But KC isnt for Greg Cook…

football Gods where are you….

His Jersey # should be retired
Absolutely!

Man what could’ve been if they had the medical technology then as they do now. If I’m not mistaken his procedure was the same one Bress had. Only they absolutely butchered people back then. Cook was before my time but my father talks about him every now and then and he gets a mix of excitement and sorrow at the thought of Mr. Cook. It really is a tragedy that such great talent and the life of a great man was cut so short.

Mike Brown said it best

Thanks for the article and Mike Brown’s quote here.
Greg Cook was the most gifted football player ever drafted by the Bengals’ franchise.
What a loss. What a class act. What a tragedy. What memories, but cut short once again.

I’ll never forget the game at (then) Nippert stadium, when Greg and his fellow teammates pulled off the win against the Chiefs that left everybody, around the NFL, completely incredulous on that Sunday afternoon. I don’t think i’ve attended a football game, since then, that i got more pleasure from.

I’ll never forget when it became official that GC had decided to give up his dream of a career, at the professional level, in the game that he was born to excel at. The injury had upset Bengals’ fans at the time of its occurrence; but that was nothing like the disappointment that we felt for Greg and the team, when it was definitely over for him as a player.

Whenever i think of GC, i can’t help but feel sad. However, i don’t think that he looked at his life feeling terribly sad.

What a loss of a great player, but the loss of Greg Cook, the person, is that much more difficult.

You must Login with your SB Nation account and be a member of Cincy Jungle to post a comment.